Publications
Richard E. Ma yer has made major contributions to Educational Psychology since the 1970s, including work on learning in mathematics, creativity, interest, measurement, problem solving, and especially multimedia learning, defined as learning from instructional material that includes information in both verbal and visual form. In a 2024 reflection, Mayer called for identifying boundary conditions—i.e., moderators of effects—of his multimedia design principles. In an effort to identify these, we meta-analyzed Mayer's corpus of multimedia research. We searched Google Scholar, PsycINFO, and the Cambridge Handbook of Multimedia Learning 3rd Ed. for peer-reviewed articles on multimedia learning with Mayer as an author published 1990–2022 and located 92 articles reporting on 181 studies reporting on 591 separate effects. We coded for 9 moderators: multimedia design principle, multimedia type, age, academic domain, country/continent, treatment duration, dependent variable type, year, and authorship order. We analyzed the Hedge's g effect sizes using a multilevel regression approach in the metafor package in R. The overall effect was g = 0.37, which was significantly moderated by all moderators, including a small decline in effect size per year. Mean effects by multimedia design principle were uneven, with the largest significant effects for removing seductive detail, modality principle, personalization, multimedia principle, sentence-level coherence, and self-explanation. Medium significant overall effects were found for the testing effect, scaffolding, cueing, and embodiment. Large, consistent effects were found for text + diagrams across factual, inferential, and transfer outcomes. Less-consistent effects were found for animation, games, and simulations, with smaller effects on factual learning and on average larger effects on inferential and transfer outcomes, but no significant effects for virtual reality. We identified two boundary conditions in tests of design principle x DV type interactions and Multimedia type x DV type interactions. We close by interpreting various findings in phases of Mayer's work, characterized by collaborators and educational technologies. We also contextualize Mayer's findings within recent meta-analyses of the larger published research on various design principles.
Student during-learning data such as think-alouds or writing are often coded for use of strategies or moves, but less often for what knowledge the student is using. However, analyzing the content of such products could yield much valuable information. A promising technique for analyzing the content of student products is semantic network analysis, more widely used in political science, communication, information science, and some other social science disciplines. We reviewed the small literature on semantic network analysis (SemNA) of individuals with relevant outcomes to identify which network analysis metrics might be suitable. The Knowledge Integration (KI) framework from science education is discussed as focusing on amount and structure of student knowledge, and therefore especially relevant for testing with SemNA metrics. We then re-analyze three published think-aloud data sets from undergraduate students learning introductory biology with the metrics found in the literature review. Significant relations with posttest comprehension score are found for number of nodes and edges; degree and betweenness centrality; diameter, and mean distance. Inconsistent results possibly due to text-specific features were found for number of clusters, LCC, and density, and null results were found for PageRank centrality and centralization degree. Basic principles from the KI framework are supported-amount of information (nodes), connections (edges, average degree), key ideas (degree and betweenness centrality) and length of causal chains (mean distance and diameter) are related to posttest comprehension, but not density or LCC. Possible explanations for slight variations across data sets are discussed, and alternative theories and metrics are offered.
One of the newest types of multimedia involves body-connected interfaces, usually termed haptics. Haptics may use stylus-based tactile interfaces, glove-based systems, handheld controllers, balance boards, or other custom-designed body-computer interfaces. How well do these interfaces help students learn Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM)? We conducted an updated review of learning STEM with haptics, applying meta-analytic techniques to 21 published articles reporting on 53 effects for factual, inferential, procedural, and transfer STEM learning. This deposit includes the data extracted from those articles and comprises the raw data used in the meta-analytic analyses.


