Publications
Building on previous work to understand mental transformation of solid objects, our work aims to contribute to theory on how individuals visualize fluid transformation. Working at the intersection of discipline-based research in fluid-Earth sciences (oceanography and atmospheric science) and cognitive science, we began by characterizing students' mental models of fluids in solid body rotation. Using a common pedagogical tool of oceanography and atmospheric science instructors—large water filled rotating tanks—we conducted semi-structured, interactive interviews in conjunction with demonstrations of solid body fluid rotation to elicit participants' sketched predictions and explanations of their reasoning. We used emergent coding to analyze the data and found that participants confidently predicted fluid behavior; however, their predictions were highly inaccurate, much to the participants' surprise. These results suggest that the behavior of rotating fluids is unintuitive, and that the mind adopts prior experiences with fluids to fill the gap. We suggest that a better understanding of how humans reason about fluids can inform the cognitive science of event processing and suggest that framing mental transformation using an event perspective may be a productive approach.
Hydrogeology is a sub-discipline of geoscience that is highly spatial. The goal of this study was to quantify the relationship between spatial thinking skills, experience, and performance on an assessment of hydrogeology content knowledge. We categorized items from the hydrogeology content knowledge assessment as spatial or non-spatial in order to investigate whether spatial thinking skill affects performance on both sets of items. Undergraduate students, graduate students, and professional hydrogeologists (N = 72) completed two measures of spatial thinking skills, the hydrogeology content assessment, and a domain and experience questionnaire. We performed Pearson's correlations between the measures, hierarchal regression analysis using spatial thinking skills and experience as predictor variables for performance on the spatial and non-spatial items from the knowledge assessment, and PROCESS macro to perform moderation analysis. On spatial items, experience predicted 20.3% and spatial thinking skills predicted 11.2% of the variance in performance. On the non-spatial items, experience predicted 28.0% and spatial thinking skills predicted 5.4% of the variance in performance. The moderation analysis revealed that the effect of spatial thinking skills on performance on spatial items was higher at average and higher levels of experience, implying that experience provides an advantage in knowing when and how to use spatial thinking skills. This study suggests that researchers and educators need to consider how content assessment items are written, as successful performance may require spatial thinking skills in addition to knowledge.
The Auvergne district has an outsize influence in the history of geology, in large part because it is one of the most accessible volcanic fields in western Europe.These volcanoes of central France first erupted ~100,000 years ago and stopped ~10,000 years ago.The Auvergne volcanic district is also known as the Chaîne des Puys, with a "Puy" referring to a rounded hill (Fig. 1).When geologists first worked in the Auvergne district, Neptunism was the dominant model
The geoscience education research community has invested in research of students' understanding of large magnitudes as it applies to deep time and worked to apply findings to improve teaching and learning in geology courses. Building on this research and encouraged by efforts to expand beyond studies of solid Earth science, we posit that fluid-Earth sciences such as oceanography and atmospheric science require facility with small numbers and suggest that parallel investigations of students' understanding of small numbers would broadly support geoscience education, while adding to emerging cognitive science theory of how individuals conceptualize and estimate small magnitudes. We reviewed textbooks from oceanography, atmospheric science, and geology as proxies for small number use in introductory courses. We found in the introductory level textbooks we reviewed, oceanography and atmospheric science use small numbers and small units at a rate of two to three times that found in geology. We conducted two number line experiments (Experiment 1, N = 185; Experiment 2, N = 80) to identify student errors with small number estimation and compared error patterns to large number estimation and previous work. Our findings include a pattern of overestimation at smaller values and underestimation at larger values within small magnitude categories. These patterns are consistent with less variability when estimating familiar magnitudes and greater variability when estimating unfamiliar magnitudes. We conclude that learning about small scale Earth processes may be as challenging for students as learning about geological time scales and propose that investigations into student understanding of small numbers are likely to yield education and cognitive science insights as valuable as those from prior investigations of large numbers.
A typical classroom exercise in hydrogeology is to develop a conceptual model of a contaminated site, identify groundwater flow direction(s), and predict the location and mass of a contaminant plume. This requires knowledge of key hydrogeological concepts and is highly visuospatial in nature. Among multiple discrete spatial thinking skills identified by cognitive science, the combination of visual penetrative ability and working in multiple frames of reference were identified to significantly predict performance on a hydrogeology task and showed that together with hydrogeology knowledge, these spatial thinking skills account for 49% of the variability on task performance. Seventy-two hydrogeology practitioners and students with varying levels of expertise were administered multiple spatial thinking tests and an assessment of hydrogeology knowledge before completing a hydrogeology task that was developed for the study. Using spatial thinking and knowledge test scores as predictor variables, a hierarchical regression analysis was conducted with performance on the hydrogeology task as the outcome variable. The resulting model predicts that at low levels of hydrogeology knowledge, the identified spatial thinking skills account for more than a 25% difference on the hydrogeology task. This study provides empirical evidence that visual penetrative ability and working in multiple frames of reference are important skills in hydrogeology; thus, instructors are encouraged to recognize that underdeveloped spatial thinking skills could present hurdles for students and that targeted spatial thinking training may yield positive results for both weak and strong spatial thinkers.


