Publications
Abstract This mixed‐methods study examines the experience of the impostor phenomenon in a racially/ethnically and sexually diverse sample of undergraduates in majors related to science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM). Guided by an intersectionality framework, we examined whether experiences of the impostor phenomenon differ at the intersection of race, ethnicity, and sexual identity. Survey data from undergraduate STEM students ( N = 735), consisting of 559 (76%) racial/ethnic minorities, 169 (23%) lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer/questioning (LGBTQ) individuals, and 119 (16.2%) racialized LGBTQ individuals, revealed racial/ethnic and LGBTQ differences in the impostor phenomenon. Findings also suggest that STEM students with at least one mentor reported lower levels of impostor phenomenon. This finding was not moderated by race/ethnicity or sexual identity, suggesting that mentoring may be a form of social support that offers equivalent benefits to students from diverse STEM educational backgrounds. To supplement the quantitative findings, we collected open and closed‐ended data from participants. Thematic analysis of these data provides insight into the range of coping strategies STEM students use when experiencing the impostor phenomenon. Implications and recommendations for research, theory, and policy are further discussed.
External review letters (ERLs) play a critical role in the promotion and tenure (P&T) process. However, recently, scholars have questioned their validity, given the strong relationships between letter writer characteristics and letter content. Building on Madera et al. (2024), we develop a social role-based theory of how letter writer gender affects letter content and voting outcomes. Results from within-candidate analysis find gender differences in letters written for the same candidate, 1) men letter writers used more personal pronouns (I/me/myself) and women used more other-pronouns (she/he), 2) letters written by women - compared to men - had a more positive tone overall, and 3) used less doubt language. Collectively, this suggests that women write more supportive and candidate-focused letters than men in the P&T process. Confirming this, we find that - controlling for school, discipline, scholarly productivity, and demographics - candidates with a higher proportion of women letter writers (i.e., lower proportion of men) have more positive P&T outcomes. These findings underscore the need for P&T reforms to improve equity in the external review letter-writing and writer selection process. • Gender biases influence the content of external review letters (ERLs) in the promotion and tenure (P&T) process. • Women letter writers use less doubt language, fewer personal pronouns, more other pronouns, and a more positive tone than men. • A higher proportion of women letter writers is linked to fewer negative votes at the college level and a higher chance of provost approval.
Engineering bridge and success programs have been used to support the transition and retention of students in engineering and computing majors at 4-year institutions in the U.S.Many bridge and success programs also aim to broaden participation in engineering and computing by recruiting underserved students such as underrepresented minorities (URMs), women, first-generation students, and low socio-economic status (SES) students.However, their program leaders frequently report difficulties recruiting students from these groups.There is little literature focusing on the recruitment of bridge and success programs.Understanding effective recruitment strategies to reach and convince underserved students to participate in those programs can increase the use of effective practices by program leaders and disseminate best recruitment practices.Our research aims to identify which recruitment strategies are in use, which are most effective, and barriers to communicating with prospective underserved students of the engineering bridge and success programs.The research project includes several stages, investigating perspectives from both program leaders and students.This stage of the study will explore the effectiveness of different communication channels and change agents to reach and persuade underserved students to participate in engineering bridge and success programs from program leaders' perspectives.This is an explanatory sequential mixed method study based on the Diffusion of Innovations (DOI) theory framework.This work-in-progress (WIP) paper will report on instrument development, sampling procedure, planned data analysis, and current progress.This research will also broaden knowledge on applying DOI theory to increase recruitment effectiveness.
This work-in-progress research paper explores the efficacy of a small-scale microelectronics debugging education intervention utilizing quasi-experimental design in an introductory microelectronics course for third-year electrical and computer engineering (ECE) students. In the first semester of research, the experimental group attended a debugging “mini lecture” covering two common sources of circuit error and received a debugging cheat sheet with recommendations for testing and hypothesis formation. Across three debugging problems, students in the experimental group were faster by an average of$1: 43$and had a 7% higher success rate than the control group. Both groups demonstrated a strong general growth mindset while the experimental group also displayed a shift in their debugging mindset by perceiving a greater value towards debugging. Though these differences are not yet statistically significant, the pilot results indicate that a mini-lecture and debugging cheat sheet are steps in the right direction toward improving students' readiness for debugging in the workplace.
ABSTRACT Learning assistants (LAs) help implement evidence‐based teaching in undergraduate active‐learning courses and support student learning through their facilitation. Here, we present a drivers‐of‐LA‐action model with empirical evidence that connects across the macro level of LA‐supported course design and the micro level of LA‐student interactions to understand how course activity system design drives LA goals, actions, and student in‐the‐moment learning in interactions. Our study is guided by sociocultural theory, specifically: cultural historical activity theory, which helps us understand how different course components work together; and theory on authoritativeness and dialogicity, which helps us understand the centering of one canonical perspective versus multiple student perspectives. Our embedded multiple case study includes narratives of LA facilitation based on recordings of LA‐student interactions from 37 different LAs in 10 chemistry and physics courses and semistructured stimulated recall interviews with professors as main data sources. Our findings show that course design that supports targeting the canon directly versus through scientific knowledge‐building drives LA purposes to be either uni‐ or multi‐directional, LA facilitation to be authoritative or dialogic, and student in‐the‐moment learning to be LA‐ or student‐centered. We discuss the use of the drivers‐of‐LA‐action model in practice for intentional course design that integrates LAs to meet student learning goals.
The COVID-19 pandemic revealed substantial health disparities, disproportionately impacting Black individuals, individuals of lower socioeconomic status, and older adults in the US. Little is known as to whether and how adults discuss these disparities with their children, an essential first step toward determining when and how children come to understand these differences. To address these questions, we recruited parents with at least one child aged 5-12 (N = 443, 61% White) from CloudResearch Prime Panels. We asked participants to report their likelihood of discussing these disparities with their children, how they would explain them, their own beliefs regarding these disparities, and a series of group perception and attitudinal measures. An ordinal mixed-effects regression revealed that parents were significantly more likely to say they would discuss the age disparity than the race and class disparities, with no difference between the latter. Parents of older children reported being more likely to discuss race and age disparities than parents of younger children. Ordinal logistic regressions revealed that parents reported they would discuss the race disparity significantly more when they held stronger racial essentialist beliefs, held stronger racial social constructionist beliefs, and perceived Black people as warmer and less competent. Parents also reported that they would discuss the social class disparity significantly more when they held stronger essentialist beliefs about social class. Qualitative coding revealed that parents' potential explanations for the disparity and reasons to discuss the disparities (or not) with their children differed by dimension. Finally, parents' own beliefs about the existence, nature, and causes of these disparities predicted the likelihood that they would discuss them with their children -- though differently for the different dimensions. Overall, our findings suggest that parents' likelihood of discussing health disparities reflects three key factors: their own beliefs about whether/how such disparities exist, their attitudes toward the affected groups, and their comfort in discussing social issues with their children.
Many tasks feel like chores, while others are fun. Why? Here we leverage a popular puzzle game, Sokoban, to explore potential sources of variation in how enjoyable different levels of this game are to solve. In Sokoban, players navigate a grid world, pushing boxes onto goal locations while avoiding getting stuck. We first analyzed natural game play statistics (n = 442 puzzles) and found that some variation in enjoyment ratings could be jointly predicted by surface-level features (e.g., puzzle area) and solution complexity. Next, we measured how much participants reported enjoying a puzzle immediately after attempting it (N= 250 participants). We found that on successful attempts, participants enjoyed it more when they took fewer moves, whereas when unsuccessful, having made more moves was associated with greater enjoyment. Together, these studies advance understanding of how both features of the task environment and the dynamics of exploration make some activities more fun than others.
The present study investigated the extent to which linguistic features of children's stories (analysed using automated techniques), predicted human-rated Creative Expressiveness and Logic scores (both assessed with the Consensual Assessment Technique). A sample of 160 children (Mage = 8.99 years, SD = 0.3) wrote stories based on three pictures. Eleven linguistic characteristics were measured: Length, Grammar, Originality, Controlled Lexical Diversity, Uncontrolled Lexical Diversity, Divergent Semantic Integration (DSI), Referential Cohesion, Narrativity, Syntactic Simplicity, Word Concreteness and Deep Cohesion. The results showed that 51 % of the variance in Creative Expressiveness was explained by Length, DSI, Originality, Grammar, and Controlled Lexical Diversity ( sr 2 = 0.01 to 0.14). In comparison, 28 % of the variance in Logic scores was accounted for by DSI, Grammar, Controlled Lexical Diversity, Syntactic Simplicity, and Narrativity ( sr 2 = 0.01 to 0.06). These findings offer insights for educational practices by identifying the linguistic characteristics relevant to children's creative writing as opposed to logical narration. • A study on human-rated creativity and computationally measured linguistic characteristics in childhood stories. • Five linguistic characteristics (length, grammar, originality, lexical diversity, DSI) predicted creativity scores. • Story length and DSI scores (ability to connect divergent ideas) were the strongest predictors of creativity scores. • To enhance creative content in storytelling, children could be guided to use diverse language. • Automated measures can complement human creativity ratings but not replace them entirely.
ABSTRACT Undergraduate research experiences (UREs) and course-based UREs (CUREs) promote students' scientific self-efficacy growth. Yet, how self-efficacy develops during research is not understood. Furthermore, what students do during research varies in ways that likely affect self-efficacy development. We sought to address these knowledge gaps by collecting scientific self-efficacy data from CURE and URE students at nine universities at the beginning, middle, and end of a single term of research. We leveraged a theoretical advancement, latent state-trait theory-revised, to disaggregate the components of students' self-efficacy into stable or trait-like self-efficacy and dynamic or state-like self-efficacy. We determined that students' scientific self-efficacy was moderately stable during their research, with the most malleable component being beliefs in their abilities to figure out data collection and explain results. We also surveyed students ∼45 times throughout their research experience to test the extent to which research hours and types of research tasks contributed to self-efficacy development. We found that students who completed more analytic tasks experienced significantly more self-efficacy growth than students who completed other types of tasks, while time spent on research was not influential. Our results illustrate the importance of engaging students in analytic tasks during CUREs and UREs for fostering their self-efficacy development. Highlight for table of contents Using latent state-trait theory-revised, we found that students' scientific self-efficacy was more stable than malleable over one research term. Beliefs about data collection and explaining results were most dynamic. Conducting more analytic tasks fostered self-efficacy, while the time spent and completion of other tasks had no effect.
Encouraging individuals, especially children, to decrease their use of natural resources is critical to creating sustainable communities. We thus investigated whether children could learn conservation strategies from an educational TV show. We measured 4- and-5-year-olds' (N = 110) knowledge, self-efficacy, and environmental worry before and after showing them an episode of the PBS show Nature Cat that either did or did not teach about water conservation. Children who watched the episode about water conservation demonstrated improved only marginally in their understanding of water conservation strategies compared to the control group, but they did become significantly more worried about the environment. These findings suggest that exposure to nature-related educational media has the potential to improve children's understanding of environmentalism and increase children's concern for the environment. Based on these findings, we suggest ways to increase the impact of environmental educational media.


