Publications
Using a robust moderated mediation approach with a socioeconomically diverse sample of 1,532 adolescents(M age = 14.61 years; 51% female; 68% White, 28% Black; 48% economically disadvantaged), this study tested whether growth mindset and behavioral engagement mediated the link between classroom quality and math and science achievement and whether effects varied by race or socioeconomic status. Student engagement, but not mindset, significantly mediated the association in both subjects. Mediation effects varied by race in math, with weaker effects for Black students, but did not differ by socioeconomic status. Findings underscore engagement, rather than mindset, as the primary mechanism linking classroom quality to academic achievement, highlighting the need for subject-specific and equity-focused strategies to support all learners.
Abstract When evaluating a two-phase intervention, the cumulative average treatment effect (ATE) is often the primary causal estimand of interest. However, some individuals who do not respond well to the Phase I treatment may subsequently display noncompliant behaviours. At the same time, exposure to the Phase I treatment is expected to directly influence an individual's potential outcomes, thereby violating the exclusion restriction. Building on an instrumental variable strategy for multisite trials, we clarify the conditions under which the cumulative ATE of a two-phase treatment can be identified by employing the random assignment of the Phase I treatment as the instrument. Our strategy relaxes both the conventional exclusion restriction and sequential ignorability assumptions. We assess the performance of the new strategy through simulation studies. Additionally, we reanalyse data from the Tennessee class size study, in which students and teachers were randomly assigned to either small or regular class types in kindergarten (Phase I) with noncompliance emerging in Grade 1 (Phase II). Applying our new strategy, we estimate the cumulative ATE of receiving two consecutive years of instruction in a small versus regular class.
Ph.D. training across academic disciplines has faced significant challenges, with news and media outlets regularly highlighting student struggles, including frequent distrust and antagonism in relationships with faculty advisors. Given the centrality of the advisor-advisee relationship in doctoral education-most programs follow an apprenticeship model where students are mentored closely by a primary faculty advisor-the quality of this relationship may be particularly important. Yet almost no empirical research has systematically examined the long-term implications of advisor trust in doctoral education. In a prospective longitudinal study of 558 incoming Ph.D. students-primarily in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) fields-at three US research universities, we examined the role of Ph.D. students' trust in their advisor early in graduate school on 17 outcomes measured repeatedly during students' first year, a sensitive period when a disproportionate number of students have historically exited. Results revealed a surprisingly broad and consistent effect of advisor trust, such that students who had greater trust in their advisor finished their first year more motivated, higher in well-being, and more academically successful than those with lower advisor trust. These effects were independent of student and advisor demographics, students' academic preparation, individual characteristics, and existing differences in outcomes measured at the start of graduate school, highlighting the potential causal implications of advisor trust for shaping a successful and healthy Ph.D. journey.
Studying 5.6 million biomedical science articles published over three decades, we reconcile conflicts in a longstanding interdisciplinary literature on scientists' life-cycle productivity by controlling for selective attrition and distinguishing between research quantity and quality. While research quality declines monotonically over the career, this decline is easily overlooked because higher "ability" authors have longer publishing careers. Our results have implications for broader questions of human capital accumulation over the career and federal research policies that shift funding to early-career researchers - while funding researchers at their most creative, these policies must be undertaken carefully because young researchers are less "able" on average.
The current work aims to better understand student course experiences for those who reported negative perceptions in introductory physics. We conducted semistructured interviews with 24 students who reported negative perceptions of their class on a screening survey. Participants were asked to share general reflections on challenges and successes they experienced, as well as their reflections on specific aspects of the course (e.g., experiences with instructors and peers). Interview transcripts were then coded to identify the types of experiences students reported, whether they were experienced as positive or negative, as well as the themes and features associated with those experiences. Experiences with the classroom, course structure, instructors, and exams were most frequently reported as negative. Experiences with peers, help-seeking, course curriculum, and specific learning activities were the most positive, although only experiences with peers had more positive than negative reports. We then used a framework [M. D. Seery, The biopsychosocial model of challenge and threat: Using the heart to measure the mind, ] to interpret the common instructional, cognitive, and motivational themes and features reported across multiple contexts. We discuss the implications of the results for theory and practice.
Creative thinking is a primary driver of innovation in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM), allowing students and practitioners to generate novel hypotheses, flexibly connect information from diverse sources, and solve ill-defined problems. To foster creativity in STEM education, there is a crucial need for assessment tools for measuring STEM creativity that educators and researchers can apply to test how different teaching approaches impact scientific creativity in undergraduate education. In this work, we introduce the Scientific Creative Thinking Test (SCTT). The SCTT includes three subtests that assess cognitive skills important for STEM creativity: generating hypotheses, research questions, and experimental designs. In five studies with young adults, we demonstrate the reliability and validity of the SCTT – including test-retest reliability and convergent validity with measures of creativity and academic achievement – as well as measurement invariance across race/ethnicity and gender. In addition, we present a method for automatically scoring SCTT responses, training the large language model Llama 2 to produce originality scores that closely align with human ratings – demonstrating STEM-specific, automated creativity assessment for the first time. The full SCTT, along with the code to automatically score it, are available on a repository in the Open Science Framework.
Hydrogeology is a sub-discipline of geoscience that is highly spatial. The goal of this study was to quantify the relationship between spatial thinking skills, experience, and performance on an assessment of hydrogeology content knowledge. We categorized items from the hydrogeology content knowledge assessment as spatial or non-spatial in order to investigate whether spatial thinking skill affects performance on both sets of items. Undergraduate students, graduate students, and professional hydrogeologists (N = 72) completed two measures of spatial thinking skills, the hydrogeology content assessment, and a domain and experience questionnaire. We performed Pearson's correlations between the measures, hierarchal regression analysis using spatial thinking skills and experience as predictor variables for performance on the spatial and non-spatial items from the knowledge assessment, and PROCESS macro to perform moderation analysis. On spatial items, experience predicted 20.3% and spatial thinking skills predicted 11.2% of the variance in performance. On the non-spatial items, experience predicted 28.0% and spatial thinking skills predicted 5.4% of the variance in performance. The moderation analysis revealed that the effect of spatial thinking skills on performance on spatial items was higher at average and higher levels of experience, implying that experience provides an advantage in knowing when and how to use spatial thinking skills. This study suggests that researchers and educators need to consider how content assessment items are written, as successful performance may require spatial thinking skills in addition to knowledge.
Developing an engineering identity is critical for supporting students' engineering career pathways. Yet, migratory adolescents are often not afforded engineering experiences to support that identity formation. Early experiences in math and science often serve as gateways to engineering careers; examining students' attitudes and beliefs in these subjects is essential to understanding identity formation. This study took an exploratory approach to examine how migratory adolescents' math and science attitudes and beliefs, specifically their interest, recognition, and performance beliefs, contributed to developing an aspirational engineering identity. Mediation analysis was used to explore how math and science interest, recognition, and performance beliefs shaped the engineering identity formation of 227 migratory adolescents. Results show that math and science interest served as both a direct pathway to engineering identity and as the essential mediator linking performance beliefs and recognition to engineering identity development. Performance beliefs and recognition operated as interchangeable predictor variables but supported engineering identity through their influence on students' interest in math and science. Multiple pathways emerged for fostering an engineering identity among migratory adolescents, rather than a singular path. These findings highlight the importance of cultivating math and science interest as a key mechanism for supporting engineering aspirations and informing future educational interventions for this underrepresented group.
Remembering the temporal context of events is difficult across the lifespan. Across many cultures and languages, people get around this problem by grounding representations of temporal events and temporal order in space. Spatial representations of time are ubiquitous, both as external tools such as calendars and in the form of a mental timeline, a linear projection of temporal order onto space. Recent research suggests that people spontaneously draw on the mental timeline to remember temporal order. However, it is unknown how the mental timeline is utilized during the encoding and retrieval of temporal information. Here, we probed how the mental timeline aids temporal memory by combining behavioral, eye-tracking, and pupillometry methods. Participants completed a visuospatial episodic memory task in which they encoded the spatial location and temporal order of images presented in sequences that were either congruent or incongruent with the mental timeline. Participants showed a strong temporal memory advantage for images presented congruent with the mental timeline compared to images presented incongruent with the mental timeline. Pupil dilation patterns revealed that information presented in congruent trials was more easily encoded and maintained in memory. Gaze movement patterns revealed that participants more accurately remembered and referenced the spatial locations of the images when recalling temporal order. Both gaze and error patterns suggested that the temporal memory benefit from congruent trials may be due to the salience of spatial memory. These findings suggest that engaging the mental timeline may allow people to leverage robust spatial memory abilities to support temporal memory.


