Publications
As more educators integrate their curricula with online learning, it is easier to crowdsource content from them. Crowdsourced tutoring has been proven to reliably increase students' next problem correctness. In this work, we confirmed the findings of a previous study in this area, with stronger confidence margins than previously, and revealed that only a portion of crowdsourced content creators had a reliable benefit to students. Furthermore, this work provides a method to rank content creators relative to each other, which was used to determine which content creators were most effective overall, and which content creators were most effective for specific groups of students. When exploring data from TeacherASSIST, a feature within the ASSISTments learning platform that crowdsources tutoring from teachers, we found that while overall this program provides a benefit to students, some teachers created more effective content than others. Despite this finding, we did not find evidence that the effectiveness of content reliably varied by student knowledge-level, suggesting that the content is unlikely suitable for personalizing instruction based on student knowledge alone. These findings are promising for the future of crowdsourced tutoring as they help provide a foundation for assessing the quality of crowdsourced content and investigating content for opportunities to personalize students' education. [This paper was published in: " L@S '21, June 22-25, 2021, Virtual Event, Germany," ACM, 2021.]
Whereas social visual attention has been examined in computer-mediated (e.g., shared screen) or video-mediated (e.g., FaceTime) interaction, it has yet to be studied in mixed-media interfaces that combine video of the conversant along with other UI elements. We analyzed eye gaze of 37 dyads (74 participants) who were tasked with negotiating the price of a new car (as a buyer and seller) using mixed-media video conferencing under competitive or cooperative negotiation instructions (experimental manipulation). We used multidimensional recurrence quantification analysis to extract spatio-temporal patterns corresponding to mutual gaze (individuals look at each other), joint attention (individuals focus on the same elements of the interface), and gaze aversion (an individual looks at their partner, who is looking elsewhere). Our results indicated that joint attention predicted the sum of points attained by the buyer and seller (i.e., the joint score). In contrast, gaze aversion was associated with faster time to complete the negotiation, but with a lower joint score. Unexpectedly, mutual gaze was highly infrequent and unrelated to the negotiation outcomes and none of the gaze patterns predicted subjective perceptions of the negotiation. There were also no effects of gender composition or negotiation condition on the gaze patterns or negotiation outcomes. Our results suggest that social visual attention may operate differently in mixed-media collaborative interfaces than in face-to-face interaction. As mixed-media collaborative interfaces gain prominence, our work can be leveraged to inform the design of gaze-sensitive user interfaces that support remote negotiations among other tasks.
College-educated women in the workforce are discovering a latent interest in and aptitude for computing motivated by the prevalence of computing as an integral part of jobs in many fields as well as continued headlines about the number of unfilled, highly paid computing jobs. One of these women's choices for retraining are the so-called coding boot camps that teach programming skills through intensive multi-week courses. This article reports on a qualitative research study focused on the Silicon Valley area of California. We used social cognitive career theory (SCCT) to investigate the larger context surrounding women entering computing professions through boot camp learning sites, including: the environment of a booming technology workforce, boot camps as learning settings, the characteristics of women who attend boot camps, how retraining at a coding boot camp influence women's computing self-efficacy and outcome expectations, and the performance attainments of women at boot camps. Interview data was collected from 14 women who had attended boot camps-first before graduating from the boot camp and again after six months in the workforce. To contextualize the computing ecosystem, we conducted single interviews with 6 boot camp organizers/curriculum developers, 7 industry hiring managers, and 14 university computer science faculty. To provide a contrast with women at boot camps, we interviewed 5 women who majored in computer science at the university and with 17 men who had attended boot camps. Structural data coding and analysis was done focused on the SCCT mechanisms of environment, person inputs, learning experiences, self-efficacy, outcome expectations, and performance attainments. Findings here demonstrate that training at a boot camp can be the catalyst for college-educated women to attain computing jobs and careers, although these entry-level jobs may be a compromise to the goal of a software development job and are unlikely to lead to a job at large, well-known, established technology companies.
With the global movement to incorporate computer science instruction into elementary education, learners are being introduced to computer science and computational thinking (CS/CT) ideas at increasingly younger ages. At these early ages, young learners are developing cognitive abilities foundational to their education. While other discipline-based education fields, such as math, science, and reading, have long studied the role of cognitive abilities, such as short-term working memory and long-term retrieval, in their respective fields, similar research in computer science education is relatively sparse. In this exploratory study, we examined the relationship between cognitive abilities and CS/CT performance of fourth-grade students (ages 9-10) who underwent either an introductory CT curriculum based on Use->Modify->Create or the same curriculum with additional scaffolding from the TIPP&SEE metacognitive learning strategy. Our analysis revealed performance on CT assessments to be weakly correlated with working memory and long-term retrieval, with correlations increasing as the CT concepts grew more complex. This suggests that scaffolding beyond TIPP&SEE may be needed with more complex CT concepts. We also found that when using TIPP&SEE, students scoring below average on cognitive ability tests performed as well as students in the control condition with average cognitive ability scores. These results indicate TIPP&SEE's potential in creating more equitable computing instruction. We hope that results from this initial exploration can help encourage further study into the role of cognitive abilities in CS/CT education for young learners.
The effectiveness of user interfaces are limited by the tendency for the human mind to wander. Intelligent user interfaces can combat this by detecting when mind wandering occurs and attempting to regain user attention through a variety of intervention strategies. However, collecting data to build mind wandering detection models can be expensive, especially considering the variety of media available and potential differences in mind wandering across them. We explored the possibility of using eye gaze to build cross-domain models of mind wandering where models trained on data from users in one domain are used for different users in another domain. We built supervised classification models using a dataset of 132 users whose mind wandering reports were collected in response to thought-probes while they completed tasks from seven different domains for six minutes each (five domains are investigated here: Illustrated Text, Narrative Film, Video Lecture, Naturalistic Scene, and Reading Text). We used global eye gaze features to build within- and cross- domain models using 5-fold user-independent cross validation. The best performing within-domain models yielded AUROCs ranging from .57 to .72, which were comparable for the cross-domain models (AUROCs of .56 to .68). Models built from coarse-grained locality features capturing the spatial distribution of gaze resulted in slightly better transfer on average (transfer ratios of .61 vs .54 for global models) due to improved performance in certain domains. Instance-based and feature-level domain adaptation did not result in any improvements in transfer. We found that seven gaze features likely contributed to transfer as they were among the top ten features for at least four domains. Our results indicate that gaze features are suitable for domain adaptation from similar domains, but more research is needed to improve domain adaptation between more dissimilar domains.
Despite the abundance of data generated from students' activities in virtual learning environments, the use of supervised machine learning in learning analytics is limited by the availability of labeled data, which can be difficult to collect for complex educational constructs. In a previous study, a subfield of machine learning called Active Learning (AL) was explored to improve the data labeling efficiency. AL trains a model and uses it, in parallel, to choose the next data sample to get labeled from a human expert. Due to the complexity of educational constructs and data, AL has suffered from the cold-start problem where the model does not have access to sufficient data yet to choose the best next sample to learn from. In this paper, we explore the use of past data to warm start the AL training process. We also critically examine the implications of differing contexts (urbanicity) in which the past data was collected. To this end, we use authentic affect labels collected through human observations in middle school mathematics classrooms to simulate the development of AL-based detectors of engaged concentration. We experiment with two AL methods (uncertainty sampling, L-MMSE) and random sampling for data selection. Our results suggest that using past data to warm start AL training could be effective for some methods based on the target population's urbanicity. We provide recommendations on the data selection method and the quantity of past data to use when warm starting AL training in the urban and suburban schools.
Reflection plays a critical role in learning by encouraging students to contemplate their knowledge and previous learning experiences to inform their future actions and higher-order thinking, such as reasoning and problem solving. Reflection is particularly important in inquiry-driven learning scenarios where students have the freedom to set goals and regulate their own learning. However, despite the importance of reflection in learning, there are significant theoretical, methodological, and analytical challenges posed by measuring, modeling, and supporting reflection. This paper presents results from a classroom study to investigate middle-school students' reflection during inquiry-driven learning with Crystal Island, a game-based learning environment for middle-school microbiology. To collect evidence of reflection during game-based learning, we used embedded reflection prompts to elicit written reflections during students' interactions with Crystal Island. Results from analysis of data from 105 students highlight relationships between features of students' reflections and learning outcomes related to both science content knowledge and problem solving. We consider implications for building adaptive support in game-based learning environments to foster deep reflection and enhance learning, and we identify key features in students' problem-solving actions and reflections that are predictive of reflection depth. These findings present a foundation for providing adaptive support for reflection during game-based learning.
Many teachers have come to rely on the affordances that computer-based learning platforms offer in regard to aiding in student assessment, supplementing instruction, and providing immediate feedback and help to students as they work through assigned content. Similarly, researchers commonly utilize the large datasets of clickstream logs describing students' interactions with the platform to study learning. For the teachers that use this information to monitor student progress, as well as for researchers, this data provides limited insights into the learning process; this is particularly the case as it pertains to observing and understanding the effort that students are applying to their work. From the perspective of teachers, it is important for them to know which students are attending to and using computer-provided aid and which are taking advantage of the system to complete work without effectively learning the material. In this paper, we conduct a series of analyses based on response time decomposition (RTD) to explore student help-seeking behavior in the context of on-demand hints within a computer-based learning platform with particular focus on examining which students appear to be exhibiting effort to learn while engaging with the system. Our findings are then leveraged to examine how our measure of student effort correlates with later student performance measures.
Although online courses can provide students with a high-quality and flexible learning experience, one of the caveats is that they require high levels of self-regulation. This added hurdle may have negative consequences for first-generation college students. In order to better understand and support students' self-regulated learning, we examined a fully online Chemistry course with high enrollment (N = 312) and a high percentage of first-generation college students (65.70%). Using students' lecture video clickstream data, we created two indicators of self-regulated learning: lecture video completion and time management. Performing a k-means clustering on these indicators uncovered four distinct self-regulated learning patterns: (1) Early Planning, (2) Planning, (3) Procrastination, and (4) Low Engagement. Early Planning behaviors were especially important for course success-they consistently predicted higher final course grades, even after controlling for important demographic variables. Interestingly, first-generation college students classified as Early Planners achieved at similar levels as their non-first-generation peers, but first-generation students in the Low Engagement group had the lowest average grades among students. Overall, our results show that self-regulation may be an important skill for determining first-generation students' STEM achievement, and targeting these skills may serve as a useful way to support their specific learning needs.
Collaborative game-based learning environments offer significant promise for creating engaging group learning experiences. Online chat plays a pivotal role in these environments by providing students with a means to freely communicate during problem solving. These chat-based discussions and negotiations support the coordination of students' in-game learning activities. However, this freedom of expression comes with the possibility that some students might engage in undesirable communicative behavior. A key challenge posed by collaborative game-based learning environments is how to reliably detect disruptive talk that purposefully disrupt team dynamics and problem-solving interactions. Detecting disruptive talk during collaborative game-based learning is particularly important because if it is allowed to persist, it can generate frustration and significantly impede the learning process for students. This paper analyzes disruptive talk in a collaborative game-based learning environment for middle school science education to investigate how such behaviors influence students' learning outcomes and varies across gender and students' prior knowledge. We present a disruptive talk detection framework that automatically detects disruptive talk in chat-based group conversations. We further investigate both classic machine learning and deep learning models for the framework utilizing a range of dialogue representations as well as supplementary information such as student gender. Findings show that long short-term memory network (LSTM)-based disruptive talk detection models outperform competitive baseline models, indicating that the LSTM-based disruptive talk detection framework offers significant potential for supporting effective collaborative game-based learning through the identification of disruptive talk.


